The only shape we have is a rectangle (about twice the size of the bar pin).
What about using the "plastic canvas" stuff that people cross-stitch on? I *think* there are some fairly small-holed ones that would be fairly easy to cut into specialized shapes, plus would make a great gluing surface.
You might even be able to use those fancy large (1.5", 2", etc.) paper punches to punch some common shapes, like hearts.
Anyone know a better product than the cross-stitch "plastic canvas"? It's been a long time since I looked at much fiber art, and I wasn't looking at jewelry-related stuff then.